Home Up Feedback Contents Search

Monotheism
Traditional Monotheism Eastern Religions

 

 

Judaism
Christianity
Islam Norman Rockwell, "A Scout is Reverent" (1974)


Defining "Monotheism"

In its simplest terms, "monotheism" is the belief that there is one, and only one, God. It is usually distinguished from "polytheism" (a belief in many gods) and "henotheism" (a devotion to one God who is viewed as supreme without denying the existence of other gods, who are often associated with other peoples or ethnic groups). But monotheism also includes the belief that this one God is transcendent (and thus over and distinct from the material universe) and personal (able to be in some type of relationship with creation). Thus, pantheism's belief in the identity of all that is as God would not qualify it as a monotheistic religion.

Monotheism and "Western Religions"

The historical origins of monotheistic religions are widely debated by among religious studies scholars. Some describe its origins in the beliefs of Akhenaten (Amenophis IV, c. 1364-1347 BCE), sometimes called the "heretic pharaoh," whose singular devotion to the Egyptian god Aten (the solar disk) may have crossed the boundary between henotheism and genuine monotheism. Others locate its origins in the beliefs of the ancient Hebrews and Israelites that over time developed into Judaism. Both of this explanations associate it with "Western" societies as the development of monotheism was most furthered in Judaism and its related religions of Christianity and Islam.

Many scholars are now backing away from the association of monotheism and "Western" religion and cultures. The reasons for this are twofold. First, historically it is clear that the origins of monotheism on either theory do not reside in "Western" or European societies (whose indigenous religions were of the "traditional" varieties) even though over time it came to dominate the religious views of those cultures. Second, in the twenty-first century it is clear that at least for Christianity and Islam the vast majority of followers of these faith live outside "Western" countries. The country with the largest Muslim population in the world is Indonesia, followed by India (despite the fact that in India's huge population Muslims are a small minority in comparison to the Hindu majority). As the number of Christians declines in Europe, that religion's fastest growth is found in the developing regions of Africa, Asia, and Central and South America (on this point in particular, see Phillip Yancey, The Next Christendom).

The "Religions of the Book"

The practice within Islam of including Christianity and Judaism along with itself as "the religions of the book" points out both the historical interconnections between these faith traditions and the importance of scripture as a written compendium of divine revelation within them. Christianity has adopted the Jewish scriptures as a portion of its own scriptural tradition, and the Islamic scriptures have parallel accounts of some stories from the Jewish scriptures as well as mentions of Jesus as one of a series of great prophets that also include Abraham and Moses and reaching a culmination for Islam in Mohammad.

Yet while each of these religions recognizes certain commonalities as peoples who worship the one God revealed to Abraham (leading some now to call them as a group the "Abrahamic religions"), they also recognize profound differences of belief and practice between them. For example, both Jews and Muslims have serious reservations about the consistency of monotheism with the widely held Christian doctrine of the Trinity (that the one God exists eternally as "Father, Son and Holy Spirit").

The links at the left will provide brief overviews of each of these monotheistic faiths in terms of their history, their scriptures, and some basic religious practices.


Copyright © 2005 Scouting and Religious Diversity
Last modified: 10/10/05